About Us

Paper or Plastic Sports and Games first opened as a brick and mortar store in 2017. We have grown our disc golf selection since 2006 as we run local tournaments and sold discs online. Our goal with our store is for our customers to go home with a story to tell. We want to hear about the amazing D&D session where nothing but rolling a crit would have saved your party. We want to hear about the disc you purchased going out and smashing an ace that same day. We also want to give you an online shopping experience that helps us interact even better with you and make it easier to browse our full inventory.

Owner, Scott Pitner, and his wife, Sara Pitner, hope that we can provide a fun, family friendly environment for you to come and play games, have a good time, and elevate your game whether it be disc golf or tabletop games. These are our two hobbies in life, and we love sharing it with you!

We love our customers and welcome your feedback and suggestions. Use our Contact Us page to tell us what we’re doing right or what we can improve on.